Greene v. Sibley--"The Kneeling Mechanic" | 177 NE 416 | July 15, 1931 | Jonathan Zittrain

H2O

This is the old version of the H2O platform and is now read-only. This means you can view content but cannot create content. You can access the new platform at https://opencasebook.org. Thank you.

Greene v. Sibley--"The Kneeling Mechanic"

by Jonathan Zittrain
Should we consider actors to be negligent if they fail to take precautions that require little effort, and would have mitigated the risk of harm? EDIT ANNOTATED ITEM INFORMATION DELETE ANNOTATED ITEM
1

177 N.E. 416
Court of Appeals of New York.

ELIZABETH S. GREENE, Respondent, v. SIBLEY, LINDSAY AND CURR COMPANY, Appellant.

July 15, 1931

2

APPEAL from a judgment of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in the fourth judicial department, entered March 23, 1931, affirming a judgment of the Monroe County Court in favor of plaintiff, entered upon a verdict.

3

CARDOZO, Ch. J. Plaintiff, having made a purchase in the defendant's department store, stood at a counter waiting for her change. While standing there, she turned to her right and saw beside her a mechanic and a floorwalker looking at a cash register which was said to be out of order. Then she turned to her left, and gathered up her change which the shop girl had brought for her. In the meantime, the mechanic had gone down on his knees in order to look up into the mechanism, with the result that his legs stretched back upon the flooring of the aisle. Plaintiff, supposing, so she tells us, that he was standing where he stood before, and meaning to go around him, stumbled over his foot. She suffered injuries for which she sues.

4

We find no evidence of negligence.

5

The mechanic had been standing by the plaintiff, busy, as she perceived, in the repair of the machine. She had no thought that he had gone away during the moment or two that had passed in the collection of the change. On the contrary, she supposed, so she says, that he was standing where he was before. " I thought I was making a sweep around him standing there." The merest glance would have told her that instead of standing there erect, he was down upon his knees. We do not sav that there was contributory negligence on her part in the failure to be more observant of the fact that his attitude had changed. It is quite a different thing to sav that there was negligence on his part in the failure to foresee how little observant she would be.

6

7

The measure of the defendant's duty was reasonable care (Hart v. Grennell, 122 N. Y. 371, 374; Larkin v. O'Neill, 119 N. Y. 221). Looking back at the mishap with the wisdom born of the event. We can see that the mechanic would have done better if he had given warning of the change of pose. Extraordinary prevision might have whispered to him at the moment that the warning would be helpful. What the law exacted of him, however, was only the ordinary prevision to be looked for in a busy world. He was doing a common and simple act in the plain sight of those around him. The act did not involve a continuing obstruction with the indefinite possibilities of mischief that permanence implies (cf. . Ginns v. Sherer Co., 219 Mass. 18; Nye v. Liggett Co., 224 Mass. 401). It was a matter of minutes or perhaps seconds. A saleswoman who had knocked a package off a counter or a customer dropping a handbag or a glove might have done the same thing. If the kneeling mechanic gave any thought to the plaintiff standing at his side, he must have known that she had seen him at work upon his job. Was he to suppose that she would act as if he were still standing there erect when to his knowledge a mere glance would have told her something else ?

8

The judgment of the Appellate Division and that of the County Court should be reversed and the complaint dismissed with costs in all courts.

9

LEHMAN, KELLOGG, O'BRIEN' and HUBBS, J.J., concur; POUND and CRANE, J J., dissent.

10

Judgments reversed, etc.

Close

Annotated Case Information

June 02, 2014

"Greene v. Sibley"

Greene v. Sibley--"The Kneeling Mechanic"

Author Stats

Jonathan Zittrain

Expand
Leitura Garamond Futura Verdana Proxima Nova Dagny Web
small medium large extra-large