Internet & Society: The Technologies and Politics of Control Winter 2017 | Samantha Bates | December 09, 2016


This is the old version of the H2O platform and is now read-only. This means you can view content but cannot create content. You can access the new platform at Thank you.

Internet & Society: The Technologies and Politics of Control Winter 2017

by Samantha Bates Show/Hide
  1. 1 Show/Hide More Day 1: Introduction
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    Welcome! We aspire to the implausible: a nine-day introduction to the unusual dynamics of the world’s digital space, sufficient for a strategic understanding of what makes it difficult (but far from impossible) to regulate or shape; who’s trying to do it nonetheless; and how such efforts have fared over the past twenty years, with an eye towards lessons for influencing the space and the behavior within it today.

    In addition to offering some frameworks for thinking about Internet architecture and policy, and the curious open and generative nature of the phenomenon, we will delve into the net as a contingently global phenomenon, and the way that complicates regulation by traditional sovereigns. Our case study will be the current debates around implementation of Europe’s “right to be forgotten” in search engine results. As you complete the readings, you might see how you’d answer the question of what a state like France’s view should be towards the scope of its RTBF regulation, and whether the kind of “zoning” described in the Cato Institute article from thirteen years ago (!), is realizable and desirable.

  2. 2 Show/Hide More Day 2: Copyright
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    Copyright was once thought of as the defining battle of consumer networking. Academic technologies brought into the mainstream made it trivial to prepare and distribute perfect copies of copyrighted work without permission — and the comparatively powerful organizations representing copyright holders saw this as an existential threat.

    We will read some of the “grim joy” experienced by Internet freedom types in dancing on the grave of copyright in the mid-1990s — and immerse in some of the law and policy changes effected in the United States to deal with the problem without running up against the equities of rapidly-growing intermediaries of online and Internet service providers (turns out, there’s a difference).

    The copyright wars revealed a variety of strategies that we’ll look at with the benefit of years of hindsight, including lawsuits against network providers, software makers, and individual users both sending and receiving files, as well as technical changes designed to make it more difficult to share items that wish not to be shared. Ultimately we are drawn to the question of whether the wars were won by one side or another, or whether it’s more accurate to say that they simply faded away. What issues today feel make-or-break, yet could simply fade rather than be resolved, and why?

    We’ll end the day with a peek into, and practice of, a current intense if obscure debate: that of whether digital rights management hooks should be placed into standards for Web browsers.

  3. 3 Show/Hide More Day 3: Cryptocurrency
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    One view of the progression of digital technology has been roughly from amateur to professional, from open to closed, and from chaotic to ordered — as the early successes from left field of Google, Facebook, and Twitter enter publicly-traded adulthood. At the ripe year of 2017, are there still digital disruptions to be had?

    The phenomenon (and increasing literal value) of cryptocurrency — and, for that matter, the foundational blockchain technologies on which it can be based — seems to indicate that there are still surprises from left field. What does the rise of cryptocurrency tell us about the state of cyberspace, and what should we expect — and hope for — next?

      1. 3.5.4 Show/Hide More Vili Lehdonvirta and Edward Castronova, Virtual Economies: Design and Analysis. MIT Press (2014)
        Read Chapter 10: Money. Chapter will be printed for students.
    1. 3.6 Show/Hide More Ethereum
      Original Creator: Samantha Bates

  4. 4 Show/Hide More Day 4: Private Infrastructures for Government Surveillance
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    Digital privacy has at times been understood as privacy against corporate intrusion (think ad networks); against government (think the various government intelligence-gathering establishments around the world); and against one another (think drones as well as more pedestrian technologies that empower people to document facts about, or even doxx, each other).

    This session will look at the second form of surveillance, especially as effectuated through the cooperation or compulsion of private intermediaries. How successful is such surveillance, and will it continue to be effective as the public reacts by potentially adopting privacy-enhancing tools? How successful do we want it to be, and how might frameworks agreeable within jurisdictions that embrace the rule of law be used or abused within those that do not?

  5. 5 Show/Hide More Day 5: Net Neutrality and Internet Architecture
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    We increasingly assume the availability of commodity networking — a flat fee for access — even as the way in which we experience the Internet is evolving through a curious microeconomics, a mishmash of policies designed to subsidize or regulate access, and a sometime ability to arbitrage around arrangements through technologies to facilitate access sharing and virtual tunneling.

    How is Internet access likely to evolve, and what choices exist for polities with particular ideals about how it should work?

    Discussion will include Andy Ellis, Berkman Klein Center Fellow and CSO of Akamai, one of the most important companies that people haven’t heard of.

    1. 5.5 Show/Hide More Zero-rating
      Original Creator: Samantha Bates

  6. 6 Show/Hide More Day 6: Weaponized Social
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    The time when the solution to bad speech could be advanced as simply more speech might seem quaint. The famously libertarian Electronic Frontier Foundation recently released a white paper in which it acknowledged a line between a clash of ideas and flat-out harassment, with the latter causing less rather than more robust debate. Separately, concerns about outright false news that spreads virally have inspired calls for action by intermediaries like Facebook — a self-described technology, rather than media, company.

    Applying lessons from the conflicts of the past two decades online, how might we agree upon a vision for social networking even if we disagree on many substantive issues to be debated there, and what are the roles, if any, of regulators and private platforms in establishing boundaries on behavior online through code or legal sanction?

    Is it more difficult to agree on a vision is our media is no longer about the battlefield or the real world but is the battlefield and the real world?

    1. 6.1 Show/Hide More The Problem
      Original Creator: Samantha Bates

  7. 7 Show/Hide More Day 7: Free vs. Proprietary Code and Content
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    This day examines quite different models for the development and distribution of software — which can also serve as models for hardware, and for content. What kind of ecosystem, featuring what models, is desirable?

    We will think about current issues in cybersecurity as a case study in why free vs. proprietary code might matter, and take up the question of how regulation might be applied when there are no easily identified intermediaries in the production of code.

    And we will hear from the legendary David Clark, one of the framers of the Internet.

    1. 7.4 Show/Hide More Jonathan Zittrain, The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It. New Haven: 2008.
      Jonathan Zittrain, The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It. New Haven: 2008.
  8. 8 Show/Hide More Day 8: Governance and Artificial Intelligence
    Original Creator: Samantha Bates

    The tensions between free vs. proprietary software help focus us on foundational questions of governance that are threaded through the course. To what extent should new technologies be shaped and shared by anyone without gatekeeping? 2017 may find the Internet in middle age. Do its puzzles suggest anything about whether and how to resolve governance questions for more newly mainstreamed technologies like machine learning and other AI?

    In addition to the challenges that the Internet has provided in regulation and governance, the inability to really understand what many “learned” algorithms do, and their ability to have properties and abilities beyond the capabilities of their initial designers, presents additional challenges when thinking about whether and how to regulate the research, as well as the deployment, of AI. Phenomena like digital currencies and distributed AI systems reprises the ideas and challenges of Barlow’s declaration of independence of cyberspace.


Playlist Information

December 09, 2016

Author Stats

Samantha Bates

Research Associate

Harvard Law School, Berkman Center

Other Playlists by Samantha Bates

Find Items

Search below to find items, then drag and drop items onto playlists you own. To add items to nested playlists, you must first expand those playlists.

Leitura Garamond Futura Verdana Proxima Nova Dagny Web
small medium large extra-large