Hypo: Plagiarism | jdickins | June 28, 2012


This is the old version of the H2O platform and is now read-only. This means you can view content but cannot create content. You can access the new platform at https://opencasebook.org. Thank you.

Hypo: Plagiarism

An old friend of yours, Eric, sends you an email.

Here is the complete text of Eric’s email:

“Hey there! How’s my favorite law student doin’ these days? I hope all is well. . . . I’m writing you because I’ve run into a little problem, and I thought, given your legal knowledge, you could help me out. Remember Jasmine, from high school? Well, here’s an email I got from her yesterday: 

‘From: Jasmine

To: Eric

Hi, Eric. I’ve seen this quote a few times on the Internet the last couple of weeks. “Freedom is best spoken of by people who are not free; they know it in its absence in a way we who have it cannot really know it. We are wise to listen to them.” I thought it looked familiar, and then I realized that it’s from your book, right? People are stealing it like crazy! You might want to look into this. xoxo Jasmine’

Jasmine is right – those exact sentences appear on page 134 of my book. I started looking around on the Internet, and I found dozens and dozens of blogs that are using the same quote. And then this weekend, it appeared in several “op-Ed” articles in some newspapers (the New York Times and the Philadelphia Daily News, along with a couple of others). Is there anything I can do?

Your old friend,


End of text of Eric’s email

What do you tell him? In particular, does Eric have a copyright infringement claim (or claims) here?


Text Information

January 08, 2014

Professor David Post


H2O has permission to use this resource.

copyright hypo plagiarism

Author Stats


Leitura Garamond Futura Verdana Proxima Nova Dagny Web
small medium large extra-large